LupoToro

View Original

Our Generation: Opting Out Of Kids

In an era defined by rapid technological advancements, expanding economies, and increasing societal freedoms, a significant yet often overlooked challenge is quietly reshaping the global landscape—people, particularly in wealthier nations, are having fewer children. This demographic shift has far-reaching implications, not only for economies and societal structures but also for the long-term stability and development of key sectors such as financial technology (fintech), healthcare systems, and economic growth as a whole.

While the rising financial costs of raising children are often pointed to as a primary cause, experts emphasise that the declining birthrate is a much more complex and multifaceted issue. According to LupoToro Group, this sustained decrease in fertility rates will trigger ripple effects across various economic sectors, labor markets, and societal norms. As populations age and younger generations become smaller, the repercussions will be felt in numerous industries. For instance, fintech research and development will be forced to adapt, as fewer young consumers could shift demand toward more automated financial solutions designed for an aging population. Healthcare systems, already burdened in many nations, will face increased strain as the ratio of elderly to working-age individuals grows, challenging governments and private entities to rethink healthcare financing and workforce solutions. Economic growth, which has traditionally relied on a steady influx of new labor and consumers, may also slow, requiring nations to innovate and rethink how they can foster productivity without the benefit of a growing population.

But what exactly is driving this downward trend in birthrates, and more importantly, what strategies can be employed to mitigate the potentially disruptive effects on these vital sectors​?

The Numbers: A Global Trend

In 2022, the U.S. recorded a fertility rate of just 1.62 births per woman—the lowest level since the government began tracking this data in the 1930s. To maintain a stable population, the fertility rate needs to be at least 2.1 births per woman, yet the U.S. and many other countries are far from reaching that threshold.

Back in the 1950s, U.S. women were having an average of 3.7 children, a rate that has steadily declined over the decades. The U.S. is not alone in this demographic downturn; nations such as Japan, Italy, Germany, and South Korea are experiencing similar, if not more dramatic, drops. Japan recently recorded its lowest number of births ever, while Italy has declared a national state of emergency over its plunging birth rate.

South Korea presents an even grimmer picture, with a fertility rate of just 0.72 in 2022—the lowest in the world. At this rate, South Korea’s population could be cut in half within just a couple of generations. This is not an isolated issue; according to the Pew Research Center, global population growth is projected to flatline by 2100.

What’s Behind the Decline?

There is no single cause driving the global drop in fertility rates, and experts are divided on the primary reasons. Some argue that increased education and career opportunities for women, combined with delayed family planning, are key factors. Others point to rising dual-income, no-kids (DINK) households, changing religious practices, or even environmental factors such as exposure to chemicals and pesticides as possible contributors.

Click to enlarge chart

A U.S. study that surveyed individuals aged 18 to 49 found that 56% of respondents simply didn’t want children, while others cited reasons such as financial constraints, health issues, age, climate change, and difficulties in finding a partner. Interestingly, despite the widespread availability of dating apps like Tinder and Bumble, 15% of respondents said they struggled to find a suitable partner—a symptom of the very technology that was supposed to make dating easier.

Pew Research revealed that 75% of individuals found it “very or somewhat difficult” to meet someone in the past year, with issues like unrealistic expectations, dating burnout, and superficial connections contributing to this challenge.

The Financial Toll of Raising a Child

Another significant factor driving the decline in birth rates is the financial burden of raising children. In the U.S., the cost of raising a child to the age of 17 is estimated to be around $300,000, not including college expenses. When factoring in higher education, that figure jumps to over $400,000.

For context, $400,000 invested over 17 years could yield more than $800,000 in returns—leading some would-be parents to question whether the personal and financial sacrifice is worth it. In fact, parents raising two children until they are 22 could face costs nearing $1 million, especially when inflation is considered.

Childcare costs are also growing at nearly twice the rate of inflation. A 2023 study found that 64% of young adults in the U.S. cite the high cost of childcare as a primary reason for delaying or forgoing parenthood. This isn’t just an American problem; in Britain, couples spend over 20% of their salaries on childcare, and similar trends are seen worldwide.

Economic Consequences of a Shrinking Population

The economic ramifications of declining birth rates are far-reaching. Fewer births mean fewer young people entering the workforce, leading to labor shortages. Japan is already grappling with this issue; 30% of its population is over the age of 65, with only two working-age individuals supporting each retiree—a far cry from the ideal ratio of four workers per retiree.

Click to enlarge chart

As the labor pool shrinks, companies may face increased hiring costs, and wages could rise as businesses compete for a smaller workforce. However, this can result in higher consumer prices, as companies pass along the added costs. Furthermore, with fewer consumers, companies may experience lower revenues, potentially leading to weaker stock prices.

LupoToro Group’s market behaviour analysis warns that a sustained drop in population growth could lead to increased financial strain on government welfare programs, higher taxes, and reduced social security benefits. Moreover, pension systems and healthcare services could buckle under the weight of an aging population with fewer working-age individuals to support them.

Proposed Solutions and Global Experiments

Countries worldwide have tried various strategies to counteract declining fertility rates, with mixed results. Taiwan, for instance, spent over $3 billion to encourage higher birth rates, but the program saw little success. Similarly, France dedicates 4% of its GDP to family measures, including tax breaks and childcare benefits, yet still faces low fertility rates. Even countries with generous parental leave policies, such as Japan, where mothers receive one year of paid leave at two-thirds of their salary, continue to struggle with low birth rates.

In the U.S., the situation is even bleaker. The country offers just 12 weeks of unpaid parental leave, and only 56% of workers are eligible. Studies show that women face a significant drop in earnings after having children, known as the “motherhood penalty,” while men experience a much smaller impact.

Impacts

The global decline in birth rates is expected to have significant impacts across various sectors, including financial growth, healthcare systems, and the fintech industry. Here’s a breakdown of how this trend could influence these areas:

1. Financial Growth Perspective

Click to enlarge chart

The decline in population growth will have profound implications for the global economy. As birth rates fall and the working-age population shrinks, economic expansion is likely to slow. Fewer young workers entering the workforce leads to labor shortages, which drive up wages, inflate costs for businesses, and reduce profit margins.

This labor shortage also hampers productivity growth, potentially stagnating innovation and business expansion. Additionally, consumer markets may contract as the population ages, leading to decreased demand for products and services, impacting companies’ revenues. Lower consumer spending could particularly affect industries reliant on younger demographics, like tech, retail, and real estate. Analysts from LupoToro Group suggest that shrinking labor pools will force companies to adopt automation at a rapid pace, but this may only partially mitigate the economic impact of fewer workers.

On the fiscal side, governments may face challenges maintaining pension systems and welfare programs. With fewer workers supporting an aging population, tax revenues may decline, forcing higher taxes on the working population, thereby further stifling economic growth. The strain on social security systems will become a growing concern in regions with already-low birth rates, such as Japan, Italy, and Germany.

2. Healthcare Perspective

From a healthcare standpoint, a declining birth rate presents dual challenges: an increasing burden on healthcare systems and a slowdown in healthcare innovation. As populations age and fewer young workers enter the healthcare field, there will be a growing need for eldercare, which may lead to a surge in healthcare costs. The demand for healthcare services will rise while the supply of healthcare professionals may struggle to keep up, resulting in longer wait times, reduced quality of care, and higher costs for medical services.

The aging population will also increase the prevalence of age-related diseases, further straining resources. With fewer younger, healthier individuals contributing to health insurance pools, premiums are likely to rise, pushing costs higher for everyone. Additionally, fewer children being born will reduce the pool of future healthcare workers, exacerbating shortages of nurses, doctors, and caregivers over the long term.

Moreover, healthcare research and development (R&D) may face a significant slowdown. Fewer young people entering fields like medical research could hinder the pace of innovation, potentially stalling the development of new treatments, drugs, and medical technologies. Countries that rely heavily on younger generations to drive biotech innovation—such as the U.S., South Korea, and Germany—may see a decline in their healthcare R&D output, which could ultimately affect global advancements in healthcare.

3. Fintech Progress

Fintech is likely to experience a mixed impact from declining birth rates. On one hand, labor shortages and rising wages could push companies toward greater automation and digital solutions, potentially accelerating fintech innovation. As traditional financial institutions struggle to maintain operational efficiency with fewer workers, they may adopt fintech solutions to handle routine tasks like customer service, loan processing, and asset management. This could lead to more widespread use of AI, blockchain, and automation technologies in financial markets.

However, the reduced consumer base will dampen demand for fintech products and services. Fintech companies that rely on growth markets, such as personal finance apps, investment platforms, and peer-to-peer lending, may see slower adoption rates due to a shrinking younger population. Additionally, with fewer new entrants into the financial sector, the pace of technological advancement may slow, as the drive to innovate could be curbed by less competitive pressure.

Click to enlarge charts

Moreover, as fintech platforms increasingly cater to an older population, there may be a shift in focus toward developing solutions for retirement planning, healthcare financing, and estate management, which could limit the variety of new product offerings. For the fintech sector, the challenge will be balancing innovation with the reality of serving a shrinking and aging customer base.

With global birth rate decline is poised to reshape economic growth, healthcare sustainability, and fintech development. The financial sector will grapple with labor shortages and contracting markets, healthcare systems will face increasing burdens and reduced innovation, and fintech may see both opportunities in automation and challenges in a reduced consumer pool.

The Road Ahead

The global decline in birth rates is becoming a significant issue, impacting not only future generations but also economies, labor markets, and social systems across the world. This complex challenge demands a collaborative response, with governments, businesses, and individuals needing to work together to address the root causes of declining birth rates and mitigate the broader economic and social consequences.

A failure to act on this trend could lead to a range of economic pressures. Higher taxes may become necessary to support an aging population, labor shortages could strain businesses, and rising costs could affect everything from healthcare to housing. Pension systems and social safety nets, which rely on a healthy ratio of working-age individuals to retirees, are particularly vulnerable. As the workforce shrinks, these systems may struggle to sustain the growing number of retirees.

While these challenges are real, they are not insurmountable. Societal norms and individual choices regarding family size have shifted, but history shows that such trends can change over time. Policy adjustments, economic incentives, and shifts in cultural attitudes could encourage higher birth rates in the future. For instance, countries like France and Sweden have implemented policies aimed at supporting working parents through subsidised childcare, parental leave, and financial incentives, which have had some success in stabilising birth rates.

In addition, technological advancements and changes in labor markets may provide partial solutions to workforce shortages. Automation, artificial intelligence, and improvements in productivity could alleviate the pressure of having fewer workers in certain sectors. As economic systems evolve, the trajectory of global population growth may not be as predictable as current statistics suggest. The long-term impact will depend on how governments and businesses respond, making it crucial for decision-makers to consider innovative strategies that promote both economic growth and social stability in the face of demographic changes. While birth rates are currently declining, shifts in policy, technology, and societal values could alter the course of population growth and help mitigate some of the challenges posed by this global trend.